It’s the sound of the police

Much has been written in recent weeks about the alienation of young people from society. I’ve already explained why I think this is a parental issue far more than a societal one, but I’d also add that it’s actually quite difficult to bring young people into the (big) society fold. Young people (and by this I really mean teenagers) are not exposed to many of the important issues that are faced by adults. As a teenager, you are shielded by your parents, or at least you should be. You shouldn’t need to worry about getting a job, renting/buying a house etc, and the people that you deal with on a day to day basis (your friends) aren’t ready to contribute much to society either, and this is exactly as it should be. Teenagers are often by nature non-conformists; they’re keen to rebel, albeit usually in a harmless way, against their parents, teachers and polite society in general. Very few people dress like they did when they were a teenager, and listen to the same music; many of us take up, and then give up, smoking as teens. This is all part of growing up; it’s doesn’t suggest any fracture within society, but teenagers are always going to exist on the margins of society – there’s plenty of time for them to become their parents later on.

When one becomes an adult, it’s far easier to define yourself as a useful, upstanding member of society. But what does one have to do to achieve this? I think that most people would agree with that the following is key: be employed, and to earn one’s keep, ideally in a job where you are clearly performing a useful role in society, and not earning far more than perhaps your contribution would suggest is reasonable.

I think most people could suggest a job that fits this criteria (nursing, teaching), and could also suggest some that would not (banking). One job that clearly fulfils the above would be the police. It’s a job with difficult hours, the pay is reasonable but no more, it’s essential to society.

So why do we continually run down our police force? Why have the policemen and women become the target for such criticism and marginalisation from all angles?

To quote examples – lack of riot training/riot equipment for police to deal with the recent troubles, major Government cuts to the police, accusations of police brutality (Ian Tomlinson), accusations of police timidity (London riots), people spectating at the riots in London, the goading of the police by rioters more interested in capturing evidence on their phones than making a political point. Even the title of this piece is taken from a piece of music criticising police brutality, though the real meaning of the song has been lost amid the amusing siren sounds, and though none of us pay any real attention to them, the sentiments can become lodged. None of us are surprised to hear Dr Dre’s line of ‘so muthaf*ck the police’, and none of us are shocked as we would be were he criticising an ethnic minority, or women. There is an inherent need for young people to rebel, but should we still be doing the same thing against our police force as adults?

The most obvious contrast from the police would be the British Army. My brother was an officer in the cavalry for a decade, and has since joined the metropolitan police. I’ve never had the conversation with him, but I suspect that he’s quite surprised about the difference in public feeling towards the two (fairly comparable) roles. The British Army are often referred to as heroes, and the charity ‘Help for Heroes’ is now one of the richest in the UK. How about a similar charity for police officers wounded in the riots? Would there be a similar outpouring of national feeling (and cash)? Maybe it’s because the Army are sorting problems in foreign lands, where the local people there deserve all they get, and maybe here our natural inclination is an anti-authority standpoint where we regress to our teenage feelings of rebellion towards those that enforce polite society, but it seems like a confused message to give.

So who feels more alienated from society – the teenager, who has yet to have the chance to contribute, or the police officer, providing a vital role than many of us wouldn’t do for twice the money, and being pilloried by the very society that they protect?

3 thoughts on “It’s the sound of the police

  1. Hi Ben – what a great post. I couldn't agree more with what you say about the police. A very close friend of mine was a police officer and the way she approached her job was nothing less than inspirational. Thanks for writing this – I just wish more people thought like you..

  2. I suspect there are a lot of people that agree. I have no connections with the police but unending respect for the job they do. Seems they do a fairly thankless task under great difficulty most of the time.

    That said I think the riots go into a far greater society issue that both police and teachers seem to be left trying to guide against fluctuating political agendas.

    We seem to have a section (small but nonetheless recognisible) of society that somehow has grown up with no real sense of purpose, place or direction. With no one to give them hope or self respect, they seem to require material assets. Their demands for things they feel they have a right to, not necessarily earned, is increasingly fierce.

    Maybe time for us to accept that Society has simply changed. I suspect all of us will no longer be able to re-create what has gone before and need to accept, with dignity, that we either work three times as hard as our parents did to achieve the same (and my parents worked hard), or accept that life is pretty good lived a little more simply. So here's to picking berries of hedgerows, enjoying rays of sunshine in our lovely parks, and the blessing of another day with good friends tomorrow.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s